Quick Verdict
Most warmup tools are the same repackaged SMTP relay with a nicer dashboard, and half of them will get your domain flagged if you point them at a brand-new inbox. If you send under 500 cold emails a month, Instantly or Warmbox will do the job without you thinking about it. If you’re running real volume, Lemwarm is the only one I’d trust with a domain I actually care about.
Mailreach **** (4/5) — boring in the best way Instantly **** (4/5) — warmup is basically free with the sender Warmbox *** (3/5) — decent, weird pricing Lemwarm ***** (4.5/5) — the one I keep paying for Warmy *** (3/5) — fine until support ghosts you TrulyInbox *** (3/5) — good idea, clunky execution Mailwarm ** (2.5/5) — fell behind, don’t bother
The embarrassing part
I nuked a client’s domain in February. Not "oops deliverability dipped" nuked. Fully nuked. Spam folder on Gmail, Outlook, and — somehow — a university alumni server I didn’t even know existed.
Here’s what happened. I’d been hand-warming a fresh Google Workspace inbox for three weeks, sending myself emails from a personal account, replying, marking not-spam. Very diligent. Very stupid. Then I got impatient, hooked the domain to a Smartlead campaign, and pushed 800 emails in four days because a deadline I’d agreed to was suddenly real.
By day five, nothing was landing. The client found out before I did because their CFO got a "your email was blocked" bounce. That call was fun. I sat on mute for most of it and nodded at a webcam.
So now I pay for warmup tools like a person who’s been burned. Because I have been.
Mailreach
Mailreach is the Toyota Camry of warmup. Not exciting, doesn’t break, gets you there. The network is real humans and real inboxes, which matters more than any dashboard metric they show you. I’ve had a domain go from "constantly in promotions" to "lands in primary" in about 11 days with Mailreach doing its thing in the background.
What I hate: the UI looks like it was designed in 2016 and then abandoned. The reporting is fine but you have to dig for anything useful. And the pricing creeps up on you — the base plan covers one inbox, then suddenly you’re paying per mailbox and it’s not cheap anymore.
Instantly
If you’re already using Instantly for sending, the warmup is essentially bundled. Free with the plan, and it works. The network is big and the engagement looks organic enough that Gmail doesn’t flag it, which is the whole point.
Honestly? The worst part is how aggressively they upsell you on everything else. Every login is a new feature announcement. Every email is a "did you know." I get it, you have a growth team. Please.
Also the warmup settings default to something aggressive that I had to dial back after one domain got a soft warning. So check those before you walk away.
Warmbox
Warmbox does the job. I ran it on three inboxes for six weeks and didn’t see anything break. Deliverability stabilized, no drama.
The pricing model is the weird part. It’s not bad, it’s just confusing — different tiers get different features that don’t obviously map to anything. I had to email support to ask whether the plan I wanted actually included what I needed. That’s a bad sign. Instantly costs $37/mo for sending plus warmup; Warmbox wants $29 for warmup alone if you pick the mid tier, and you’re basically paying for features you’ll never touch. TrulyInbox is $15 and does roughly the same thing. Pick based on the network, not the price tag.
Lemwarm
This is the one. Lemwarm is part of the Lemlist ecosystem and it’s the only warmup tool I’ve used where I’ve actually seen a measurable difference in reply rates on cold campaigns. The warmup emails feel real because they basically are — it’s a network of actual senders, not bots.
What I hate: Lemwarm alone is $29/mo per inbox, which adds up fast if you’re running 10 mailboxes. And you can’t use it standalone without a Lemlist account, so you’re sort of roped into the ecosystem. Not a huge deal if you’re already there.
Small tangent: I once ordered a cortado at a coffee shop that turned out to be a Lemwarm user. We talked for 20 minutes about deliverability and I missed a Zoom. Worth it.
Warmy
Warmy’s pitch is decent — AI-driven engagement that adapts to your sending patterns. It does work, mostly. I ran it for a month on a domain I didn’t care about and saw reasonable improvement.
Then I had a billing question and support took nine days to reply. Nine. Days. For a $19/mo tool. I’m not saying they’re a scam, I’m saying don’t expect a human when something breaks.
TrulyInbox
TrulyInbox is cheap and the concept is solid — warmup plus a deliverability audit that flags issues before they become problems. It caught a misconfigured SPF record on one of my domains that two other tools missed. That’s real value.
The execution is rough. The dashboard is slow. The onboarding flow asks you the same question three times in different ways. I got halfway through setup, closed the tab, and came back two days later because I couldn’t be bothered.
Mailwarm
Mailwarm used to be the standard. Now it feels like it’s coasting. The network is smaller than it was, the engagement patterns are predictable, and I’ve had domains plateau after two weeks of running it.
For $15/mo it’s not going to kill you, but you’re paying for a brand that peaked. I’d skip it.
Pros & Cons
Mailreach
- Real human network, actually moves the needle
- Reliable, won’t break your setup
- UI is stuck in 2016
- Pricing gets expensive per inbox
Instantly
- Bundled free with sending plans
- Big network, organic-looking engagement
- Constant upselling
- Aggressive defaults you have to fix
Warmbox
- Stable, no surprises
- Decent network size
- Confusing pricing tiers
- Features you’ll never touch
Lemwarm
- Best deliverability improvement I’ve measured
- Real senders, not bots
- $29/mo per inbox
- Requires a Lemlist account
Warmy
- Cheap, adaptive engagement
- Works for basic warming
- Support takes forever
- Not great for high volume
TrulyInbox
- Deliverability audits catch real issues
- Cheapest option at $15/mo
- Slow dashboard
- Repetitive onboarding
Mailwarm
- Cheap
- Was the standard once
- Small network
- Predictable patterns, plateaus fast
Pricing at a Glance
| Tool | Starting Price | What You Actually Get | |——|—————|———————-| | Mailreach | $25/mo | One inbox, real human network | | Instantly | Free with sending plan | Bundled warmup, aggressive defaults | | Warmbox | $29/mo | Mid-tier features you won’t use | | Lemwarm | $29/mo per inbox | Best results, ecosystem lock-in | | Warmy | $19/mo | Basic warming, support roulette | | TrulyInbox | $15/mo | Warmup + deliverability audit | | Mailwarm | $15/mo | Small network, dated approach |
FAQ
Q: Is email warmup actually necessary for cold outreach? A: Yes, unless you enjoy watching bounces roll in. New domains and inboxes have no sending reputation, and warmup builds it before you start pitching strangers.
Q: How long does warmup take before I can send cold email? A: Two to four weeks minimum on a fresh domain. Anyone telling you three days is selling you something. I learned this the expensive way.
Q: Which warmup tool is best for a single Google Workspace inbox? A: Mailreach or Lemwarm. Mailreach if you want simple, Lemwarm if you want the best results and don’t mind the price.
Q: Can I use warmup tools with Instantly or Smartlead? A: Yes, they run alongside. Instantly has its own built in, and Lemwarm, Mailreach, and Warmbox all play fine with external senders.
I run Lemwarm on everything I care about and Mailreach on the side inboxes where I just want it to work. Two tools, about $70 a month, and I haven’t had a domain die since February.


🖼️ Looking to upscale your images?
Try our free AI image upscaler — upload any image and get a 4K high-resolution version instantly. No signup required.
Upscale Your Images Free →Free 2K preview · 4K download just $2.99 · One-time payment